In-depth Analysis of the "Surge" Problem in High-Capacity Centrifuges
Release time:
2016-09-28
Overview:
High-capacity centrifuge Thanks to its exceptional “large capacity,” it has become a dominant force in the centrifuge industry. However, this very “large capacity” has also brought about a challenge for the company itself—“surge.” For a long time, effectively controlling surge in high-capacity centrifuges has proven to be an especially tricky issue within the industry. Indeed, if any centrifuge manufacturer were to master the art of mitigating—or even completely overcoming—the problem of centrifuge surge, it would undoubtedly achieve a major breakthrough in its industry development. Today, our editor will take you on an in-depth exploration of the phenomenon of “surge” in high-capacity centrifuges. 。
Shanghai Luxiangyi Centrifuge Instrument Co., Ltd. has found that high-capacity centrifuges primarily operate in three main modes: differential centrifugation, density-gradient centrifugation, and rate-zonal centrifugation. According to the company’s centrifuge technicians, further in-depth research and improvements on these three methods could help alleviate, to some extent, the issue of “surge” commonly encountered in high-capacity centrifuges. First, let’s briefly explain these three methods:
The differential centrifugation method using a high-capacity centrifuge is a kinetic technique that leverages centrifugal force to separate substances with different sedimentation coefficients. In this method, a centrifuge tube containing a heterogeneous mixture of particles is placed in a benchtop high-capacity refrigerated centrifuge and spun at high speed. Particles of varying sizes and densities will migrate toward the bottom of the centrifuge tube at their respective sedimentation rates. By carefully controlling the rotational speed and duration, the particles with the highest sedimentation rate will settle first at the bottom of the tube, while those with intermediate and lower sedimentation rates will remain suspended in the supernatant. By transferring the supernatant into another centrifuge tube, increasing the rotational speed, and maintaining a specific duration, it is possible to isolate the components with intermediate sedimentation rates. By repeating this process multiple times, different components can be effectively separated. The isopycnic density-gradient centrifugation method—also known as isopycnic banding centrifugation—utilizes the principle that when particles of different densities are subjected to centrifugal force, they either sink downward or rise upward, continuously migrating along the density gradient until they reach a point where their density exactly matches that of the surrounding medium, thus forming distinct bands. The position and shape of these bands remain unaffected by the duration of centrifugation, as the system reaches a dynamic equilibrium. The rate-zonal centrifugation method—also referred to as rate-zonal banding centrifugation—is performed using a benchtop high-speed refrigerated centrifuge. It relies on the differing sedimentation rates of particles in a density gradient medium, allowing particles with various sedimentation rates to occupy distinct density-gradient layers and thereby form separate zones, achieving their effective separation. Law.
Then for High-capacity centrifuge A preliminary analysis of the “surge” phenomenon has been conducted. A common issue is the surge phenomenon that frequently occurs in centrifugal chillers—centrifugal refrigeration units often experience surge. The operating principle of a centrifugal refrigeration compressor involves compressing a refrigerant with a large molecular weight by forcing it into a smaller space through high-speed motion, followed by condensation via cooling. In centrifugal chiller units, energy regulation is achieved by adjusting the angle of the high-speed rotating guide vanes to control the compression ratio. When the cooling load decreases, the work done by the guide vanes diminishes, causing the pressure of the gas being compressed to approach the pressure of the gas drawn into the compressor. This leads to gas backflow, resulting in mechanical forced vibrations—also known as “surge.” Surge can cause damage to mechanical components.
Scale buildup on the inner surfaces of the heat exchange tubes in the condenser of a high-capacity centrifuge—particularly in open-loop cooling water systems—is prone to occur, leading to an increase in thermal resistance and a decline in heat transfer efficiency. This, in turn, causes the condensing temperature to rise or the evaporating temperature to drop. Moreover, due to untreated water quality and inadequate maintenance, sand, impurities, algae, and other substances tend to accumulate on the inner surfaces of the heat exchange tubes, further raising the condensing pressure and potentially triggering surge in the test centrifuge.
Condenser fouling: Remove deposits from the heat transfer surfaces and clean the cooling tower.
When the large-capacity centrifugal unit is undergoing testing, since both the evaporator and the low-pressure piping are under vacuum conditions, air can easily leak into the connections. Moreover, air is a non-condensable gas with a very high adiabatic index. When air accumulates in the upper part of the condenser, it causes an increase in condensing pressure and condensing temperature, thereby triggering surge in the test centrifugal machine. Insufficient circulation of cooling water in the cooling tower and excessively high inlet water temperature can also lead to surge due to poor cooling performance of the cooling tower, resulting in excessive condensing pressure. Additionally, an excessively low evaporating temperature in the evaporator—caused by insufficient refrigerant in the system, reduced cooling load, or insufficient opening of the ball valve—can result in low evaporating pressure and subsequent surge. Failure to reduce the guide vane angle and lower the exhaust pressure of the test centrifugal machine when shutting down can also contribute to surge. When... High-capacity centrifuge During shutdown, the sudden loss of boost pressure can cause high-pressure refrigerant vapor from the volute and condenser to flow backward, easily leading to surge.
Air Removal from the System: When using K11 refrigerant in large-capacity centrifugal chillers, if the liquid temperature exceeds 28°C during testing, it indicates the presence of air in the system. The removal procedure is as follows: Start the vacuum recovery unit to expel the non-condensable gases. Typically, reduce the pressure of refrigerant R11 to slightly below the saturation pressure corresponding to the liquid temperature—specifically, to a pressure of 117.68 kPa or lower, which corresponds to a temperature below 28°C.
Surge occurs after startup: Perform anti-surge control. When the energy regulation is significantly reduced, it leads to insufficient intake flow—meaning that the steam cannot enter the impeller uniformly—resulting in a sudden drop in discharge pressure. As a consequence, the compressor enters an unstable operating region and surge occurs. To prevent surge, a portion of the compressed steam can be bypassed from the discharge pipe directly back to the evaporator. This not only prevents surge but also benefits the centrifugal compressor during startup: reducing steam density and lowering the discharge pressure during startup helps decrease the starting power.
Low Evaporator Pressure: Check the cause of the low evaporator pressure. If the refrigerant level is insufficient, add more refrigerant. If the cooling load is low, close the energy-regulating vanes.
Surge during shutdown: When shutting down the test centrifuge, pay attention to whether the main motor is reversing. As much as possible, reduce the guide vane angle to lower the pressure at the exhaust port of the test centrifuge.
During the operation of a high-capacity centrifugal machine, the condensing pressure and evaporating pressure should be kept stable, ensuring that the refrigeration capacity of the test centrifugal machine exceeds the refrigeration capacity corresponding to the surge point, thereby preventing surge.
Surge in high-capacity centrifuges is a killer for these machines. High-speed refrigerated centrifuges and ultrahigh-speed refrigerated centrifuges are particularly prone to surge, which, in severe cases, can damage components such as the centrifuge rotor. The above analysis—based on our many years of experience in centrifuge manufacturing, R&D, and sales—is aimed at identifying the causes of centrifuge surge and proposing effective solutions. We hope this will be helpful to those who are still struggling with... High-capacity centrifuge A little bit of help for you, who are troubled by “surge”!